“It’s a machine. Check it like one before you hand over your money.”
The Car Man
The same steps I’ve used since 1989, in order. Check them off as you go, or print the sheet and take it with you.
00
Know the Value Before You Go
Your price range
What’s a good deal?
Great dealFair dealPaying too much
Near trade-in valueSomewhere in the middleFull retail
Great deal: if you can get it close to trade-in value, that’s a wonderful deal. Grab it (if it passes the inspection).
Fair deal: most good buys land somewhere in the middle, between trade-in and retail. Where exactly depends on your local market.
Try not to pay retail. Especially from a private seller; they don’t have a dealer’s overhead.
Condition decides where it lands. Only a truly mint, museum-piece car with full records is worth the top of the book. If it’s not, you don’t need to pay top dollar. Price the faults.
JAMIE’S TIPPrice the faults, not the car. Everything you find in the steps below gets a dollar amount, and that comes off your offer.
RED FLAGSalvage, rebuilt or flood title, or a VIN that doesn’t match everywhere. Walk away unless you really know what you’re buying.
02
Get a Pro Inspection (Best Move You Can Make)
JAMIE’S TIPIf the monitors show “not ready,” the codes may have been cleared recently to hide a problem. Ask the seller why.
Can’t get it to a shop? At a bare minimum, go through every step below yourself before you hand over a dime.
03
Walk Around the Car
04
Tires, Wheels & Front End
What tire wear tells you
Center worn: overinflated
Both edges worn: underinflated
One edge worn (inside or outside): alignment out, possibly worn suspension parts
Cupping / scalloped patches: worn shocks or struts
Feathered, saw-tooth feel across the tread: toe alignment off
Flat spots: hard braking or sat for a long time
How old are the tires?
Find “DOT” on the sidewall. The last four digits are the week and year it was made: 2419 = 24th week of 2019.
Many automakers say replace tires 6 years after they were made, even with good tread; tire makers put the outside limit at 10 years. A 3-digit code means it was made before 2000: replace it.
05
Look Underneath
RED FLAGRust that’s eating into the body or frame, or any oil or transmission leak. Stop and get it professionally evaluated before you go any further.
06
Pop the Hood (Engine Cold)
RED FLAGMilky oil cap, white sludge or oil in the coolant can mean coolant and oil are mixing (head gasket or worse). Pink, milky transmission fluid can mean a cracked radiator is leaking into the transmission: it may shift fine today, but not for long. Pass until a pro checks it.
07
Start It Up
08
Inside the Car
RED FLAGA warning light that never comes on at all when you turn the key. Some sellers pull the bulb or fuse to hide an airbag or check engine problem.
09
Test Drive: At Least 20 Minutes
10
Trunk, Paperwork & Records
JAMIE’S TIPA well-maintained car with records is worth paying a little more for. No records means you’re guessing how it was treated.
This checklist is a guide to help you spot problems. It isn’t a substitute for a professional pre-purchase inspection. When in doubt, have a trusted mechanic look it over before you buy.